Makeup

Under Eye Concealer: How to Choose and Apply It

How to pick an under eye concealer shade and formula, and apply it without creasing.

Liquid concealer tubes and a blending sponge on a beige tray, pin for under eye concealer Save

Quick answer: The best under eye concealer is a creamy, flexible formula one to two shades lighter than your foundation, applied in a thin layer and set with a light powder. Use only products made for the eye area: the FDA says not to use cosmetics near your eyes unless they are intended for that use, because some color additives are not approved for the eye area (FDA).

How to apply under eye concealer: 7 steps

  1. Prep. Pat on a light eye cream and wait a minute.
  2. Correct if needed. A thin peach or orange corrector goes on first for blue or purple tones.
  3. Dot, don’t paint. Place three small dots near the inner corner and outer edge.
  4. Blend with your ring finger or a damp sponge. Tap, don’t rub.
  5. Build slowly. Add a second thin layer only where needed.
  6. Set lightly. Press a small amount of loose powder with a small brush.
  7. Check in daylight. Look for creases and tap them smooth.

How to choose an under eye concealer

ChoiceOptionsTip
Shade1 to 2 shades lighter than foundationToo light can look grey on deeper skin
UndertonePeach, yellow, neutralPeach suits many under-eye areas
FormulaLiquid, cream, stickCreamy formulas crease less on dry skin
FinishRadiant, natural, matteRadiant or natural looks softer here
CoverageLight to fullMedium is easiest to blend

We haven’t lab-tested these options. The table compares them by what the label says and how they’re usually made.

How to stop under eye concealer from creasing

  • Use less. Thick layers settle into lines.
  • Let eye cream sink in first. Too much slip makes concealer move.
  • Set with a light hand. A dusting of powder is enough.
  • Blot midday. Tap creases with a clean fingertip or damp sponge.
  • Try a setting mist. A light setting spray can soften powder.

Eye area safety tips

  • Use products made for the eye area. The FDA says not to use cosmetics near the eyes unless they’re intended for that use.
  • Don’t share. The FDA advises against sharing eye cosmetics.
  • Wash your hands and tools. Clean sponges and brushes often.
  • Keep caps closed. Store products below 85°F, as the FDA suggests for eye cosmetics.

These points come from the FDA’s eye cosmetic safety page (FDA). The FDA also notes there is no US law requiring expiration dates on cosmetics (FDA), so toss concealer that smells or separates. Patch test anything new. The AAD suggests applying a new product to a quarter-sized spot on the underside of your arm or the bend of your elbow twice a day for 7 to 10 days, and stopping if your skin reacts (AAD).

Under eye concealer in your makeup routine

Most people apply foundation first, then concealer, so you use less. See our guide on how to apply foundation for that step, and how to do makeup for the full order. On light days, concealer alone with a tinted moisturizer looks fresh and natural.

If you prefer a soft, barely-there look, pair a thin layer of concealer with the steps in our natural makeup look guide. Remove eye makeup gently each night, as in our night skincare routine.

Under eye concealer mistakes to avoid

  • Going too light. A very pale shade can look grey or chalky.
  • Drawing a big triangle every day. Target only the areas you want to brighten.
  • Rubbing. Dragging the skin moves product and feels rough.
  • Heavy powder. Too much powder makes the area look dry.
  • Skipping removal. Take off concealer gently every night.

Related guides: Color Corrector for Dark Circles: How to Use It, Concealer for Mature Skin: What to Look For.

FAQ

What shade should my under eye concealer be?

Usually one to two shades lighter than your foundation, with a peach or neutral undertone.

Should I put concealer on before or after foundation?

Most people apply it after foundation so they need less concealer.

How do I stop concealer creasing under my eyes?

Use a thin layer, let eye cream sink in first, tap to blend and set with a light dusting of powder.

Can I use any concealer under my eyes?

Use products intended for the eye area. The FDA says some color additives aren’t approved for use near the eyes.

Do I need a color corrector too?

Only if you have strong blue or purple tones. A thin peach or orange layer under concealer can help.

Written by Mahmoud Abdelmaksoud.

Written by

Mahmoud Abdelmaksoud

Mahmoud Abdelmaksoud is the founder and editor of Real Skin Routine. He is not a dermatologist or a doctor. He is a beauty writer who reads ingredient labels, brand guidance and published sources from groups such as the American Academy of Dermatology and the FDA, then turns them into simple, budget-friendly routines for skin, hair, body, makeup and nails. Each guide links to its sources and dates its prices, and posts are updated when new information comes out. His goal is to help you build an easy routine you enjoy, without hype. For personal skin or health questions, please talk to a qualified professional.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *